When Does Compromise Become Too Much in a Relationship?

When you're dating someone you really like, how do you decide which differences you're happy to accept and which ones you aren't? After all, nobody is going to tick every box. But sometimes we can be so attracted to someone's good qualities that we underestimate the importance of the things we're not really sure about.

I once dated a man who seemed to have so much of what I was looking for. He had a confident, masculine personality and a successful career, and I really enjoyed spending time with him. He made an effort, we had fun together, and I could see the possibility of a future.

But there were differences I noticed quite early on. I love going out, trying new food, and keeping relatively fit. He was the opposite, and I began to wonder whether our different lifestyles might become an issue. I remember being a little disappointed, but decided it wasn't a big deal. After all, nobody is going to tick every box. There was something else, though. He'd told me early on that he didn't want to talk about emotions. At the time, I didn't think much of it and thought everything would be okay.

When the things you overlook start to matter

As we spent more time together, I became more invested in the relationship. I liked him, and I was still attracted to the qualities that had drawn me to him in the first place.

But halfway through spending a day together, he suddenly went quiet. Everything had seemed fine to me, so I was confused about what had changed. When I tried to understand what was wrong, he didn't want to discuss it and became angry. That's when I realised that something I'd dismissed as a minor doubt was actually very important to me in a relationship - the ability to talk about our emotions and how we're feeling. That experience made me reconsider the other compromises I'd been making, and I began to realise that we were too different.

Why we sometimes overlook differences that matter

Looking back, I think one reason I'd been so willing to compromise was the picture I'd formed of him early on and the hopes I had. He had qualities I really valued, and as my feelings grew, so did my desire to make things work. I focused on everything I liked about him and convinced myself the rest wasn't important. By the time I realised how much those differences mattered, I'd developed strong feelings for him. This made ending the relationship difficult, even though I knew it was the right decision for me.

There's also something in psychology called the sunk cost effect. It's when we continue with something because of how much time, effort or money we've already put into it, even when walking away might actually be better for us. In relationships, we might think about how much time we've spent together, everything we've been through, and how much we've invested emotionally. The more we invest, the harder it can be to walk away.

Of course, having feelings for someone is a perfectly valid reason to want to make a relationship work. But I think it's worth questioning whether we're staying because the relationship is making us happy, or because we've already invested so much in it.

Knowing what you can and can't compromise on

When you're first getting to know someone, you can't always tell which differences will end up mattering to you. Something that gives you doubts at first might turn out to be unimportant, while something you've barely considered could become a much bigger issue.

I don't think we should walk away at the first sign of uncertainty, but I do think we should pay attention to what we're learning about someone, especially when it relates to something we've experienced in the past.

And if those doubts turn into real problems, we need to do something about them. Talk about what's bothering you and see whether the other person is willing to work through it with you. Because if you're constantly the one making compromises while the other person doesn't try to meet you halfway, you're likely to end up unhappy and unfulfilled in the relationship.

Next
Next

Feeling lonely this Christmas? Make the most of the freedom you have